Autocrit vs. ProWritingAid

Photo of author

Candace Osmond

Candace Osmond studied Advanced Writing & Editing Essentials at MHC. She’s been an International and USA TODAY Bestselling Author for over a decade. And she’s worked as an Editor for several mid-sized publications. Candace has a keen eye for content editing and a high degree of expertise in Fiction.

Whether you’re a blogger or an author like me, you need an editing tool to eliminate spelling and grammar mistakes. Even after more than 20 books, 5 screenplays, and a decade’s worth of content creation, I still use editing tools daily.

Two editors that correct more than your surface errors are AutoCrit and ProWritingAid. They can also fix your pacing, writing style, and readability. 

This AutoCrit vs. ProWritingAid review will show you their similarities and differences in features and pricing. Find out which editing tools are best for the type of writer you are. 

What is AutoCrit?

Autocrit 1

AutoCrit is a great tool for fiction writers who want to change their manuscripts into transformative stories. 59,000 people use this online editor to revise and edit their works using 25 tools.

Only AutoCrit has multiple features for fictional texts. For instance, if you’re a romance writer like me, you can choose “Romance” in the options for tailored suggestions. You can even analyze your work against notable authors like Stephen King, J.K. Rowling, etc. 

This writing and editing tool is the brainchild of an author who wanted to receive unbiased feedback on her work. She acknowledges the importance of critique partners, writers’ groups, and other beta readers. But she also wants purely objective suggestions for her work.

The best-in-class platform is designed for both beginners and professionals alike. Unlike other AI editors, it also guarantees you won’t lose your voice when you follow its suggestions. 

AutoCrit also features an exclusive AutoCrit Members Community for members who want to collaborate and connect regularly. It hosts live events, inviting authors, publishers, editors, and more.  

Benefits of AutoCrit 

AutoCrit is an excellent editor for fiction writers who can’t afford to hire a human proofreader. Here are some

Improves Your Prose

The software program improves your prose through its Summary Report breakdown. AutoCrit shows you your overall score and scores for each category: dialogue, pacing and momentum, repetition, word choice, and strong writing.

Go to specific tools like “Pro Writing” or “Repetition” to fix these issues. The application will take you directly to the online text editor to resolve each problem.  

If you’re worried about repetitive words and phrases in sentence structure, AutoCrit also runs multiple analytical reports for you. It gives you information on word frequency, repeated terms, and phrases.  

AutoCrit doesn’t offer detailed suggestions for your readability. But it still gives you reports like the typical Flesch-Kincaid, Smog, and Dale Chall. It will highlight “problematic words” according to the Dale Chall formula, which you can edit or delete. 

Genre-Based Suggestions

Not all online writing assistants can give you tailored recommendations for your writing. Thankfully, AutoCrit lets you set the genre of your manuscript before analyzing the whole document. This feature is helpful because each writing genre has its own characteristics.

A state-of-the-art AI tool should differentiate these stylistic traits to analyze essential components of your book. AutoCrit gives different suggestions for your thriller story and romance novel. 

Go to “Genre Selection” and select the type of writing. The genre-based suggestions also let you compare your work to others so you can emulate their style. We’re talking about Danielle Steel, Dean Koontz, Emily Griffin, and more. 

Edit by Chapter

AutoCrit is ideal for book authors and long-form content writers. Fine-tune your writing chapter by chapter by enabling the “Analyze by Chapter” option. You can skip any part of the manuscript through its drop-down menu for easier access.

But there’s a minor issue. You should have a different headline with the word “Chapter” for the app to recognize them. Otherwise, it won’t automatically separate your manuscript. 

Store Up to 50 Revisions Online

AutoCrit has a cloud storage platform where you can save up to 50 revisions of your screenplay, novel, or ebook online. Make sure to name each revision on AutoCrit. Open these files from the open file menu, edit, and the tool will autosave every change.

The writing tool’s autosave feature is beneficial, so you won’t lose your changes if your computer shuts down. You can also open each document on any device you want. 

Features of AutoCrit 

AutoCrit evaluates your work according to six categories:

  • Dialogue.
  • Word choice.
  • Persuasive writing.
  • Pacing.
  • Momentum.

As you can see, it focuses less on your mechanical errors. AutoCrit won’t help you a lot with your spelling, grammar, and readability since its suggestions are based on the elements of fiction. 

To use AutoCrit’s features, upload your manuscript to the application and choose one of the 20 reports. The application will automatically recommend modifications to your paper. 

The editing tool will track your entire progress while you’re editing. It even checks the fast-paced parts of your writing and will ask you to separate lengthy sentences.

AutoCrit also compares your work to other fictional works, a feature you won’t find on other platforms. Once you have pasted your text on the text area, go to AutoCrit’s summary report. Scroll down to see a “Compare” section. 

You can enjoy these features through an Elite subscription, which costs $80 a month. This plan includes AutoCrit’s training courses from professional editors, agents, and authors.

If you’re on a budget, AutoCrit has a Basic plan that costs $10 monthly. You can edit 1,000 words at a time under this subscription. The Professional plan costs $30 monthly with more comprehensive tools and unlimited words per check. 

What is ProWritingAid?

prowritingaid screenshot

ProWritingAid is an online writing mentor, style editor, spell checker, and grammar checker in one. I use in in combination with Grammarly to get the best of both worlds, but you don’t need to do that. ProWritingAid is considered an all-in-one tool.

The online program offers more than punctuation usage and proper verb tenses. You’ll also receive style suggestions and run your work on the plagiarism checker.

The developers designed ProWritingAid with all types of writers in mind. According to them, best-selling authors, indie writers, and copy-editors use the tool for in-depth evaluation. Students and business owners also use ProWritingAid for their essay homework. 

ProWritingAid continually undergoes research and development to make life easier for writers, pushing the boundaries of artificial technology and natural language processing.

The application features over 20 in-depth writing reports. Aside from your spelling and grammar, ProWritingAid also helps fiction writers with their pacing and dialogue tags. You can also use the thesaurus and dictionary to enhance your vocabulary. 

Organizations can also create their own style guide for automated rules and suggestions. Other features of ProWritingAid include data visualization and multiple integrations.  

Benefits of ProWritingAid 

It’s like a personal writing coach! Subscribing to ProWritingAid offers several benefits to writers and editors to create error-free writing. Here is a list of features. 

Multiple Writing Reports

prowritingaid writing reports

ProWritingAid analyzes your writing’s spelling, grammar, and style. The Writing Style Report is the most comprehensive report highlighting hidden verbs and passive voice. This report also focuses on the overuse of adjectives and adverbs and repeated sentence starts.

The online writing tool uses the latest algorithms for its Grammar Report. Use it for contextual synonyms, subject-verb disagreement, propositional usage, and punctuations. ProWritingAid will also inform you if you use a word too much in your document, then suggests alternatives.

It offers genre-specific writing style check, too, which I love for creative writing of fiction. It helps keep all my work consistent and avoids any awkward writing or lazy writing.

The online writing mentor also checks how you use pronouns. For example, newbies usually tell stories like “he did this” or “she did that,” making the text sound dull. ProWritingAid recommends that only 4%-15% of your writing should be made of pronouns. 

Cliches and redundancies are also part of ProWritingAid reports. If you worry about the length of your sentences, this grammar checker can also help you practice conciseness. 

Other writing reports ProWritingAid offers include:

  • Overused words.
  • Style issues.
  • Sticky sentences.
  • Readability.
  • Transitions.
  • Consistency.
  • Pacing.
  • Dialogue tags.
  • Diction.
  • Alliteration.
  • Homonym.
  • Acronym,
  • House style.

Extremely Accurate Suggestions

ProWritingAid is one of the most accurate AI checkers that are easy to understand and use. I tried running a piece of content on the grammar checking program. It spotted more errors than built-in spell checkers in Word and Docs.

It also saves me more time editing because it displays its corrections in real-time. Once I finished writing, I accessed the comprehensive report of ProWritingAid, seeing my overall score and other statistics. 

I can say all the suggestions are accurate, but some are not applicable. For example, I find the sticky sentences and alliteration reports unnecessary. 

Reliable Plagiarism Checker

Plagiarism detection is a favorite feature of mine when I’m looking at editing programs. Yes, the grammar tool and style guides are great, but if you’re making written content for the web, you need this distinctive feature. 

ProWritingAid offers a highly accurate plagiarism detector that scans your work against online and offline sources. It’s a powerful feature and a must-have for content creators. It finds intentional and accidental plagiarism in your work, then provides a link to the original source of your duplicate content.

Feel free to review the original source so you can cite it. You can also delete or edit your work to make it authentic. This way, you can prevent disastrous consequences for academic dishonesty.

ProWritingAid’s plagiarism checker is perfect for students and academic writers who need to cite their sources accordingly. Online content writers and bloggers can also use this tool to increase their SEO rankings on Google. But you need to purchase credits for every check.

One downside to ProWritingAid’s plagiarism checker is that it can’t spot excessively paraphrased statements. It merely finds identical or similar texts without evaluating the context of the writing.

Unrestricted Premium Plan

ProWritingAid isn’t like other editing tools that restrict paying customers. Some online writing programs have daily word or page limits for grammar checks, while others have monthly limits. Even Grammarly restricts its users to 150,000 words every month.

But you won’t experience these limitations with ProWritingAid. You can enjoy all features of the application when you purchase the license. It’s perfect for writers, businesses, and copy-editors who edit several documents within a month. 

Multiple Platform Availability

Not only is ProWritingAid available on different devices. It also integrates perfectly with various applications, making writing and editing more convenient. You can download the ProWritingAid extension on different browsers like Google Chrome.

A browser extension lets you correct your spelling, grammar, and style wherever you type, including Google Docs and Gmail. ProWritingAid also has an add-on for Safari and Firefox.

You can also download the Word and Outlook plug-in if you work on Microsoft Word. This add-in ensures you’re connected to ProWritingAid wherever you write. Even Scrivener, a word processor and organizer for long-form writers, can be integrated with ProWritingAid. 

Another advantage of ProWritingAid is that you can use it on multiple devices. Use a single subscription for your laptop, desktop, and other devices. 

AutoCrit vs. ProWritingAid 


Features: Genre-specific suggestions, word choice, pacing analysis, momentum, persuasive writing, and dialogue analysis.

Best For: Book authors who want to enhance their writing style and compare their fictional work to other writers. 

Prices: The professional monthly plan starts at $30 per month or $297 per year. 

Availability: AutoCrit web application


Features: Overused words, spelling, grammar, sticky sentences, thesaurus, personal dictionary, readability, plagiarism checker.

Best For: All types of writers who want to improve their readability and clarity.  

Prices: $20 per month, $79 per year, and $399 for a lifetime subscription. 

Availability: ProWritingAid web application, desktop application, browser extensions.

Who Should Use AutoCrit? 

AutoCrit will make the jobs of fiction authors and novelists easier. Book editors and self-publishers can also use the tool for editing writing projects. 

Whether you write Thriller, Science Fiction, or Romance, AutoCrit will give you detailed suggestions for every book genre. You can even compare and contrast your work with famous authors. 

AutoCrit gives an overall writing score to let writers and editors know which area to focus on when editing. If the story has slow-moving scenes, you can concentrate on this aspect to make it less tedious for readers. 

Self-publishers who do not have enough budget for a proofreader or editor can use AutoCrit. It picks up inconsistencies in your point of view, word choice, and dialogue.

Who Should Use ProWritingAid? 

ProWritingAid has features for fiction writers too. But bloggers, freelance writers, copywriters, and business owners can also subscribe to the web editor tool. 

The pacing, transition, alliteration, and other checks are helpful for creative writers and fiction authors. But you won’t receive suggestions based on the genre of your text, including Romance, Thriller, Sci-Fi, etc. 

Copywriters, freelance writers, and business owners can benefit from the spelling and grammar checks. ProWritingAid also keeps the formatting of your work to get it ready for online publication.

Final Thoughts on AutoCrit vs. ProWritingAid

AutoCrit and ProWritingAid have comprehensive tools to improve your writing style with top-notch writing software. They highlight spelling and grammar errors you might miss and suggest replacements to make editing more convenient.

If you’re a fiction writer who wants to focus on genre-specific recommendations, try AutoCrit. Compare your writing to prominent authors, fix your pacing, and edit by the chapter.

For content marketers, self-publishers, and fiction writers, ProWritingAid is an excellent idea. Edit your grammar, spelling, and writing style to make your text error-free.